Best Composters, Tumblers & Composting Worm Farms In 2020

If you are lucky enough to have a decent sized property, chances are you turned the backyard or the front yard into a lawn or a garden. To grow plants or grass out there, you constantly need to take care of it by watering and composting it.

Any regular homeowner would just go to the nearest superstore and buy the compost. But not you. Because you are here reading about the best composters available on the market.

We get it.

There is a unique satisfaction in creating compost on your own. Let alone the fact that you are relieved from day to day garbage disposal as well. As commercial compost is very expensive to buy in the first place, making compost by yourself is a great way to save some money and commit yourself to your garden.

Best Composters – Comparison

IM4000 Tumbling ComposterIM4000 Tumbling Composter37 GallonsTumblerCheck Latest Price
Envirocycle Composting Envirocycle Composting 35 US GallonsTumblerCheck Latest Price
Miracle-Gro DC270MGMiracle-Gro DC270MG2 x 18.5 GallonsTumblerCheck Latest Price
Good Ideas CW-2X12Good Ideas CW-2X1211 CubicTumblerCheck Latest Price
GEOBIN ComposterGEOBIN Composter216 GallonsDIYCheck Latest Price
Redmon Green Culture 65Redmon Green Culture 6565 GallonStationaryCheck Latest Price
Exaco 628001 Eco MasterExaco 628001 Eco Master120 GallonCompost BinCheck Latest Price
VermiHut 5-Tray Worm ComposterVermiHut 5-Tray Worm ComposterCompost BinCheck Latest Price
Suncast Resin Barrel ComposterSuncast Resin Barrel Composter6.5 CubicTumblerCheck Latest Price
Lifetime 60028 TumblerLifetime 60028 Tumbler65 GallonTumblerCheck Latest Price


Why Bother?

Before getting into making your own compost, you might ask yourself why you would even bother to do it in the first place. Well, there are a few reasons. Let’s get to them.

  • Making compost on your own has some efficiency perks to offer. Firstly, you don’t end up buying any compost from outside. Secondly, you are successfully recycling your garbage which is good for the environment.

Most importantly, you are doing your garden a favour by using totally organic compost instead of commercially prepared compost that tends to contain a lot of chemicals.

  • Let’s assume you are willing to make compost on your backyard. But it comes with a risk of your kids or pets making a mess out there if you are not careful. Having a proper composter will seal the elements in a secure environment where only you could access them.

Choose the Right One

When shopping for a composter, there are a few things you need to keep in mind. The first and principal one is the type. There are three types of composters widely found. They are:

  1. Continuous Composters
  2. Batch Composters
  3. Indoor Composters

Let us discuss a little about the characteristics of each type before jumping into the composters. The idea is to walk through the advantages of each and to guide you to buy the right one for you.

Continuous Composters

Continuous composters are used to make compost continuously. It’s as simple as that. Continuous composters are typically bins with a closed lid. They can handle any type of waste from your household.

The main benefit of using a continuous composter is they let you take the compost as per your convenience. The top lid is for adding the waste in. There is another door in the bottom to take out the compost throughout the year.

The advantage you get is that you can throw your day to day garbage in these continuous composters and take the compost out from the previous waste simultaneously. Ideal for homeowners who like to throw their kitchen waste and garden waste in the same bin.

Batch Composters

If you want to make your compost as fast as possible, these tumble style batch composters are the way to go. These take as less as four weeks to create compost. All you need to do is balance out the necessary ingredients and provide adequate moisture.

The reason why compost is made faster in batch composters is that are turned regularly. The turbulence creates an ideal environment for the waste to decompose and the moisture accelerates the process.

Indoor Composters

Indoor composters open up the possibility for you to compost your kitchen waste right in there. Although the scalability of the amount of the compost is compromised, these composters are ideal for places where keeping your composters outside is a problem.

The next thing to keep in mind is what kind of compost you want. Do you want a closed environment to decompose the waste or do you want live creatures to accelerate the process? Each choice asks a different type of composter.

The Best Composters For You

So, after all the things we said about composters, it’s finally time to recommend some of our favorite picks for you to choose from. We will be compiling a list with different composters with their pros and cons to make the choice as easy as possible for you.

1. IM4000 Tumbling Composter

IM4000 Tumbling Composter

Whenever a homeowner decides to buy a composter for their home, it is almost always the IM4000 tumbler or commonly known as the Yimby Tumbler. This is an octagonal composter with dual-chamber design.

The rotating design allows you to mix the compost hands-free. No need to make a mess with your hands anymore. Just turn the handle a few times a day and the composting will take its course. Hot and humid weather will accelerate the process to be finished in as less as 2 weeks.

The total capacity of 37 gallons is divided into two separate chambers. This design is very helpful to maintain a steady flow of compost for an average user. One side is open for you to add your regular waste and the other side holds the ready compost. The switch between both chambers will result in continuous production of compost.

The composter itself stands on a metal stand for better ergonomics. The handle design is great for beginners and people of any age can operate the composter. The industrial-grade plastic will not degrade under any pressure and the galvanized metal is corrosion proof.


  • Dual chambers for maximum efficiency
  • Amazing air flow with adjustability
  • Huge 37 gallons capacity
  • Ergonomic design


  • Takes a decent amount of space
  • Could be overkill for regular gardeners

2. Envirocycle Composting Tumbler

This is a great composter for homeowners with their different size homes. This composter bin comes in two different sizes and they are 17 gallons and 35 gallons.

People with large properties with large gardens and people with smaller properties can both increase the beauty of their backyard with this beautiful piece of the composter.

A unique feature of this composter than sets it apart from other manufacturers is the compost collecting base. This is an interesting innovation by Envirocycle to let you enjoy the aesthetic beauty of this product.

This tumbler is shaped like a barrel and is made from materials that are safe for food and the environment. Food safety means that the compost you are making is safe to use in your garden if you are planning to grow food plants like an apple tree.

Another great feature of this composter is its ability to provide both solid and liquid compost at the same time. When you rotate the tumbler, the top portion will hold the solid compost and the unique collecting base will collect the liquid, known as compost tea.


  • Unique collecting base to collect compost tea
  • Two different sizes to cover a wide spectrum of customers
  • Food safe
  • BPA and rust free
  • UV and antioxidant protection


  • Tilted to the expensive side
  • No stand

3. Miracle-Gro DC270MG

Miracle-Gro DC270MG

The main selling point of this particular composter is the freedom to rotate the chambers independently. Let’s admit it. There are quite a few manufacturers who offer dual chambers on their composters.

But two separate chambers? That’s pretty good. You can use it as two different composters. If you want your compost to sit idle for some time, you can always use the other chamber. You can add in waste on a regular without disrupting the decomposition of the other batch.

This composter is designed to be used heavily. Industrial grade polymer and separate chambers, what more could you ask for from a composter. Each of these chambers can hold 27 gallons of compost. So, you get a total of 54 gallons of compost which is plenty for any home user.

The aeration system is very good. Proper air and humidity have the ability to boost decomposition of the waste. So, good aeration is an important feature in any composter. Also, to further accelerate the decomposition process, mixing bars are included.


  • Separate chambers
  • 54 gallons of total capacity
  • Good aeration system
  • Reasonable price
  • Takes 4-6 weeks to show results


  • Not suitable for industrial use
  • Not suitable for huge property owners


Also Read: The Best Garden Hose Reel to Make Watering 10x Easier

4. Good Ideas CW-2X12

Good Ideas CW-2X12

Yeah, it’s a good idea to have a Good Idea at your home. Just kidding. But the Good Idea CW-2X12 is really a great composter. When other composters often come with some sort of stands to support them, this one doesn’t have them.

The logic behind not providing any legs is very obvious. As soon as you hold something off the ground, it is meant to be unstable. But the Good Idea composter eliminates the chance to fall from the legs because it doesn’t have them.

Other than superior stability over most composters in the market, this one is a very good and recommended product for city people. Each of these chambers holds only 5 gallons of compost. 5 gallons may not sound a lot but it is.

A regular city dweller usually has plants on their balcony or at the terrace. They can use this model as it doesn’t take a lot of space. The product is very efficient and easy to use. Just shove in the waste and get your compost in return.

This composter is very low key, but it doesn’t mean it lacks any quality. The aeration system is still great. It comes fully assembled so you don’t have to do it yourself. It doesn’t need any maintenance to function.


  • Very compact design
  • Suitable for occasional or amateur gardeners.
  • Very secured with large lids
  • Easy to use with no complicated assembly


  • Not suitable for larger applications
  • Quite expensive
  • Takes longer to compost

5. GEOBIN Composter

GEOBIN Composter

This composter is an example of how simple a composter can get. This is nothing but a recycled plastic bin to collect your waste. The composting is made very easy with this particular composter.

The height of this composter is only 36 inches. But the radius is adjustable according to your need. The composter is capable of holding up to 216 gallons of waste. The assembly is so simple a five-year-old kid could do it. Just unfold and assemble.

GEOBIN composter is made from 50% recycled plastic. Which means the manufacturers are trying to save the world by recycling as much plastic as possible. That is one more reason to buy this composter.


  • Huge 216 gallons capacity
  • Environment-friendly
  • Very simple and quick assembly
  • Very affordable pricing


  • Not suitable for indoor use
  • Not for outdoor use in windy regions

6. Redmon Green Culture 65

Redmon Green Culture 65

This kiwi (made in New Zealand) composter has a decent capacity of 65 gallons. It’s a resin structure that is designed for durability. The high-grade plastic is UV protected so no degradation over time.

Redmon Green Culture 65 comes integrated with ventilation holes. This ensures proper aeration to the composting process. The top lid comes off easily for your convenience. Adding household waste to this composter is as easy as opening the lid.

It features four doors on each side to access the finished compost. With an approximate weight of 15 pounds, this composter is very light to handle. It comes in two options. One option is only the composter bin and the other is with an included aerator.

When using outdoor, only the composter will suffice the aeration given the fact that it has holes all around. If you choose to get the complete package that includes the aerator, you can put it indoors as well.


  • Lightweight
  • 65 gallons capacity
  • High-quality resin structure
  • Adequate ventilation
  • Comes in two variants
  • 4 door for ease of access
  • Affordable


  • No tumbling action
  • Difficult to use in windy areas

7. Exaco 628001 Eco Master

Exaco 628001 Eco Master

If you live in the suburb areas and own a fairly big house, the Exaco 628001 Eco Master could be the perfect composter for you. Very minimalistic design with maximum efficiency. This thing is a monster when it comes to holding capacity.

The 120-gallon capacity is suitable for making enough compost to cover your large property. The composter is made from fully recycled polypropylene. The lid has wind protection so you don’t have to run outside all the time.

The aeration is enough to help the composting with narrow vents mounted on the walls. There is an extra door on the bottom from where you can access your ready compost. The design is very simple but adds a little touch of home to your house.


  • The huge capacity of 120 gallons
  • Wind protection
  • Decent aeration
  • Recycles polypropylene
  • Bottom door to access the compost


  • The material is not sturdy
  • Reported issues of plastic hinges failure
  • Heat resistance is not good


Also Read: The Best Garden Tillers to Help You Maximize your Garden’s Yields

8. VermiHut 5-Tray Worm Composter

VermiHut 5-Tray Worm Composter

The first worm composter on our list is the VermiHut 5 tray. Worm composters are different from regular plastic composters as they don’t rely on the weather to finish composting. The worms are added to finish the composting very fast.

The concept of worm composters is that the amount of worms you provide, you will get half the amount of compost. So, if you add 4 pounds of worms on the composter, you will reduce 2 pounds of household waste.

The VermiHut composter comes preloaded with 5 trays. You put the worms in the first tray from the bottom. The top trays will hold the waste. As the worms finish composting, they will automatically migrate to the upper level and start again.

Another great feature of this composter is the airflow. Air moves freely through the composter and aids the composting process even more. As the worms eat the bacteria before it starts to smell, you can even use it indoors.

Worm composters like this are a great way to reduce waste faster. It leaves no harmful footprints on the environment and is the most efficient way to make compost. With the worms in the composter, you are helping them and yourself simultaneously.


  • Very efficient
  • Environment-friendly
  • Helps to balance the ecosystem
  • Very fast composting
  • Good aeration
  • No smell
  • No bacteria infestation


  • The Aeration holes might attract flies

9. Suncast Resin Barrel Composter

Suncast Resin Barrel Composter

Yet another tumbler in our list. Tumblers are great for getting your compost fast. This particular composter from Suncast is a barrel-shaped composter for rotating action. A very light design that you can carry and place wherever you want.

The resin construction ensures a very durable and long life for the composter. Galvanized steel frame to hold the compost above the ground. The dual lids allow easy access to the finished compost and also makes it easy to put waste in.

This 49 gallons composter can make compost in less than a month. So, if you are in need of some quick compost, by all means, go for this composter. You can lock the lids buy pushing the latch. Or you can choose to ignore that because the design won’t let the lid to fall off on its own.


  • Simple yet elegant design
  • Barrel design for easier mixing
  • Decent capacity for average users


  • Quite complex to assemble
  • Relatively expensive

10. Lifetime 60028 Tumbler

Lifetime 60028 Tumbler

This composter is a great combination of lightness and durability. As it is a tumbling composter, the proper weight balance is crucial for optimum mixing ability. It has an extra-large lid for easier access.

The composter stands on a heavy-duty steel frame. The powder coating ensures that integrity is not compromised under any situation. The lid can be closed using the latches. So, no wildlife creature or your kids are able to make a food of themselves.

The capacity of this composter is 8.7 cubic feet, which translate to 65 US gallons. That is a pretty decent amount of compost for your everyday garden. The black panel retains heat very well so the composting process is much faster.

Once you put your kitchen waste inside the tumbler, you don’t have to make a mess of your clothes or smell like garbage every time you collect the compost. The sealed design of this composter holds the odor inside.


  • Balances rotation on a fixed axis
  • The moderate capacity of 65 gallons
  • Heavy duty construction for ultimate durability
  • Extra-large sealed lid
  • Powder coated steel frame for maximum stability


  • Lack of aeration
  • Fairly expensive

11. Sunwood Life Bokashi Compost Kit

Sunwood Life Bokashi Compost Kit

The word bokashi refers to organic fermented matter. This is a very effective and cheap way to ferment all your household organic waste into very rich and nutrient-filled compost. And what better mean to do it other than the Sunwood Life Bokashi composter.

The composter comes with a 5-gallon bucket, spigot and strainer, a Bokashi liquid collector and a ¾ gallon kitchen collection pail. The composter utilizes a carefully selected group of microorganisms to properly ferment the waste.

The composting process is done without the presence of air. Aeration is bad in this specific case because it cripples the microorganisms needed for the composting. The microorganisms are carried by a medium such as rice or wheat bran.

The whole process is done in a closed system. So, there is no insect infestation or a bad smell coming out. The microorganisms break down the organic waste and result in fully organic compost. Also, the process is done very fast thanks to the microorganisms.


  • Very fast composting
  • The bran is included
  • No odour
  • Environment-friendly
  • No risk of insect attack
  • Compost tea collector is included
  • Cheap and affordable


  • Very small capacity
  • Not suitable for outdoors


Composters are very useful to people who enjoy their leisure by spending time in their gardens. Some people prefer food plants such as vegetables and fruits. Some people like to plant flowers to add the aesthetic touch to the mix.

Another thing to look for when buying your first composter is whether it is food safe or not. The material of the composter hugely affects the chemical structure. Some elements like lead will contaminate the compost. Hence, look before you buy it.

Whatever your choice is, you are better off with a composer of your own. And we have mentioned the benefits of each type of composters. We have also compiled a list of our favorite picks. So, it is time for you to choose your own composter.

Related Resources:

Sean J. Stone

Sean has been a woodworking enthusiast for 8 years, and in that time has written huge resources on woodworking and tools.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments